Are Exact Match Domains Going To Get Google Slapped?
In part one I talked a bit about the history of Google slaps and Exact match domains.
We all use them, they are getting harder and harder to find with good reason, They Work!
If you can get the exact domain name for the keyword you are after then add in some good on page seo you should need to do a reduced amount of work to get to where you want.
My question is how long will the advice “buy a exact match domain and install wordpress” be the only advice that anyone seems to give newbies.
Here is a comment that was made on my first post by R W veal
I have a key worded domain .info site that ranks consistently on the first page of google for the keyword, most times more than once on the first page. However there is a .net site with the same keyword with nothing past the initial old wordpress template nothing else on the site and it is always on first page as well,
That pretty much sums up why I think a real Google slap will happen in the next 6 months to a year. When they stop messing around with Google Instant and start looking at how relevant the top 10 results are for searches they will see LOADS of domains ranking in the top 10 with nothing more than the default wordpress install.
This adds nothing of value for the searcher. But it also knocks a site that may have relevant content out of the money spots. We have all built sites which are full of useful relevant content that we can’t get to rank high enough because someone has a junk site with a exact match domain and Google seem to love it.
I don’t think the question is really IF Google will Slap Exact Match Domains, it is WHEN will they do it and the question after than is What can we do about it?
I AM NOT saying stop looking for exact match domains
I AM NOT saying dump the ones you have
What I am saying is think about what you can do to add value to the search results, don’t buy a domain name if you know you won’t ever develop it, and be prepared to do some work. The only thing that makes you money is rankings.
Top 10 is nice, but won’t make money, you NEED top 3 to even sniff at the real income potential of your site. Having the exact match domain will NOT be enough you will have to get ready for some link building.
What I do
After buying a domain I will install wordpress (no big news there) and I will write a 500+ word post using my LSI Content creator software so it features not only the main word but some related ones.
Run the site through the process I explained previously in Getting Sites Indexed
Manual Bookmarking – Jumptags and Mister Wong
This will be enough to get the site indexed, then I leave it alone for a week or two.
After a week at least I will use Market Samurai to check where it ranks for every possible keyword I can find. All too often I have already started getting emails from my Rank Tracker Plugin telling me it is already getting some rankings but I like to check anyway.
Once I know what Google think I know what to do to move on up the ranks. Not doing any link building is NOT AN OPTION if you want to avoid the wrath of Google.
Rather than making this long post even longer, I will ask you to sign up for the rss feed, or bookmark the site as I will be publishing some posts this next week on what I am doing to insulate my sites.
What I am doing to build links NOW..rather than reading stuff from a year or two ago let me share what I am using now..
Please do leave me a comment sharing your thoughts and ideas, I am off for a lie down as I think this is my longest post ever!






I can’t see how this could possibly work. We all know that despite its wealth, power and technology, Google really, really sucks at providing relevant results. If somebody buys dogtraining.com, it is a big clue for them as to what the site is about.
You would think that they would be able to analyse the content and see if it matches the theme of the domain. If they are ranking blank sites based purely on the domain name, that is something they need to sort out.
If the solution is de-indexing keywor rich domains, how would it work practically? Your site could rank for 10 keywords. Would you lose your listings for all of them if one matches the domain?
What about the number of searches. If my domain is isitoktodrycleanmypinkfurrywidget.com, would I be penalised if one person uses that search?
Look at the alternative. What if I buy a non related domain and build it as a brand. Would I be penalised if people start to search for that? Amazon would be in trouble!
I think this is a bit of nonsense and I won’t be doing anything different until I see evidence. Except…
If default wordpress installs are on the first page for decent keywords, how about contacting the owners and buying them up for cheap! Put some quality content on there and the jobs a good un.
Whose going to be the first one to right a $7 report on that?
Rich
Hi Rich
Thanks for what I think is the longest comment ever!
But what if they don’t ? What if they decide to maybe just try and show relevant results, just to try and be radical!
What if they managed to change the algorythmy thing so if it is an exact match domain with the “hello world” post it doesnt earn as many brownie points as another site.
I do not for one minute think they will de-index keyword rich domains arbitrarily (although who knows) , but I do think they will give it less weight. So if you have a domain rich keyword with relevant content and some links you should be fine.
But having a domain with the right keywords in won’t be enough anymore, and that is a good thing isn’t it?
As far as number of searches affecting whether the domain is included or ranked, (and yes it is too dry here to clean your furry widget) , I can see that more activity would be considered a good thing. If more people click through to your site then your site must be better (or at least have a better description) than the next site.
I don’t think anything will trump decent on page seo and links, or even crappy on page and links.
As far as contacting the owners of crappy sites on good domains, I would be surprised to see that no one is already doing that. The real money maker would be for anyone who can industrial size the process.
$7 reports arent my thing really so i won’t be bothering with that
Cheers for your thoughts
Paul
Hi Paul
I agree that it would be a good thing if sites without relevant content get flushed out of the listings. Leave more room for people who try to do things the right way.
As for the industrial sizing thing, surely it can’t be that difficult to write a script to search for Hello World posts.
Rich
I am not even going to start drawing the idea out, I am busy enough with Easy Spin Intro and a couple of other bits of software I want to release this year.
Paul
Hi Paul. When you mentioned your LSI Content creator software, I wanted to check it out but found no links to it on this page. I did a search for “LSI” and it only shows up once where it was mentioned. I’m sure you know this already that you should make it easy for potential customers to find your products. If it is on this page (even though I can’t find it) then I apologize.
Hi Marc
Thanks for your interest
I am actually just getting a new version made , the new images were delivered overnight and I am hoping for a release version of the software by Monday.
I expected it to already be released but of course these things never go to plan. As soon as it is ready I will let you know
Paul
History shows that Google makes a lot of changes to its algo … @ 500 changes per year in fact (OK, most of them will be minor changes).
I don’t actually mind them trying to make search results “more relevant”, as I personally try to create content-rich sites which real visitors can benefit from, so I’m sure my sites will only do better.
History also shows that people give up very easily when faced with a problem, so that will benefit the IMers who are in it for the long term.
I got hit quite badly by the MayDay changes but I’ve learned big lessons from that, and I’m now in a much stronger position than I was before MayDay.
George.
The sad thing is that I don’t think that it really matters what your site contains sometimes, I have seen just installed wordpress sites with no content ranking well. I have seen superb sites filled with useful info just floundering. I don’t think the algo is as good as we all think it is.
People want the “its easy, I don’t do any work” route for everything and of course the truth is that people spend a lot of time making sure they are an overnight success.
Paul
Great interesting topic.Personally I think Gooogle intends to frighten the daylights out us all. OK we can see plenty of evidence when they change things about, but as this conversation here states where is all this searcher relevance to appropriate content. They don’t have things sorted out the way they state.
I have a few exact match domains some doing OK, although I also have one which is .biz (All Reports Say These Are Very Difficult To Rank Well) that I will be attempting to get first page ranking. Always been a bit stubborn and curious!!!